facebook rss twitter

Wolfram Alpha goes live

by Scott Bicheno on 18 May 2009, 11:06

Tags: Google (NASDAQ:GOOG)

Quick Link: HEXUS.net/qasbn

Add to My Vault: x

Hype killer

There's been a reasonable amount of buzz surrounding a new website called Wolfram Alpha, which officially launched today. It calls itself a "computational knowledge engine" and, such is the desire for hyperbole in the world of headline writing, has been called both a ‘Google Killer' and a ‘Wikipedia Killer'.

While neither of these claims are likely to prove true, they do give us an indication where it sits in the great scheme of things. It's not a search engine because it's not designed to find web pages relevant to a search term. What it seems to specialise in is offering up data associated the query.

It will answer questions like "capital of peru", but it will give you a bunch of other, mainly statistical information on it as well as web links and a link to the Google search for the query.

 

 

The eponymous founder of Wolfram Alpha - Stephen Wolfram - offers you a guided tour to the project here. We would like to hear your first impressions of Wolfram Alpha and its possible impact on existing web search engines and knowledge bases in the HEXUS.community discussion forums.

 



HEXUS Forums :: 10 Comments

Login with Forum Account

Don't have an account? Register today!
It failed after the third itteration of the ‘random words of the top of my head typed in’ test with Domesday.

Rubbish :P

Actually for the stuff it did work with it seems pretty neat.
Anyone else getting “Wolfram and Hart” going through their head? ;)

Looks kind of interesting. I'm intrigued by the motiviation behind it, and also where Wolfram Research gets its data from since they're a private research company - I assume they're aggregating publically published statistics. Obviously I have concerns about a private company managing an apparently open data source; about how often the data is going to updated; about who is going to authenticate the information and data held; and since I work in statistic publication I always have concerns about putting that amount of data into the hands of the general public (since you don't know what they're going to do with it ;) ). Also it makes a big thing of how much data it has - but says nothing about whether it will provide information: and the difference between data and information is both subtle and *hugely* important. Add to that the fact that they'll be looking at major corporate sponsorship for raising money and you've got to ask just how impartially and responsibly the data's going to be handled.

Wow - that's a lot of concerns. Apparently I'm suspicious of it! But it's definitely an interesting idea, and I should imagine I'll follow its progress closely. It indirectly ties in with a number of strands of the work I do at the minute, so it could be a very interesting resource…
Wonder if they're hoping Google will buy them out?
Alpha has been hyped to be anything between the “best in search technology” and something that will save Google from regulatory inquiries. Seems to me, it'll be the same as the countless google-killers that came and went before it.

Scaryjim made a good point about Alpha providing data, not information. And in this sense it could be useful to scientists and students (try typing any formula in the search field). But since Google is much more general, Dr. Wolfram's creation won't really cut into its market share.
Despite what many are saying, Wolfram Alpha is not trying to compete against google. It isn't a search engin for starters.

There was a very good write up of it in New Scientist the other week.